Friday, 23 June 2017
Theatre review: Terror
This is essentially a question of morality over the literal letter of the law as Koch has not denied what he's done, it's only whether it should strictly be considered murder that's really up for discussion.
What struck me as ironic about Sean Holmes' production was how it both conforms to some German stereotypes and confounds others; the naturalistic production on Anna Fleischle's set of an imposing but generic room in a government building goes against the expressionism you'd expect from German theatre, but the precise and unemotional efficiency of proceedings totally fits other preconceptions about the Germans - I loved the impatient, clipped demands for very detailed facts from Tanya Moodie's Presiding Judge, so snippy she bordered on being like one of the eccentric judges from The Good Wife.
In a two-hour show the interval comes after 90 minutes, which makes sense in context: After the trial, the interval is time to discuss the case, and in the final 10 minutes the audience votes - with keypads attached to the seats - and we get the verdict on whether Koch is guilty or not*. von Schirach's play is interesting and certainly does inspire debate as intended, it was obvious throughout the interval that everyone was talking about it; but it's also frustrating. Forbes Masson's Defence Counsel plays slightly more to the emotions, but Prosecutor Nelson's (Emma Fielding) case is so coldly intellectual as to be self-defeating; indeed, after a prosecution that's largely relied on Immanuel Kant quotes, her closing statement concludes that philosphical arguments don't apply to the case. From a purely legal standpoint Koch is guilty (although after the verdict is given, the Judge enlightens us on a quirk of German law that might have made a difference to my point of view on that,) but Nelson's constantly missing open goals muddies the waters a lot more than the defence's attempts (why does she spend time confirming that Koch's superior [John Lightbody] thinks anyone else would have done the same thing? Doesn't it weaken her case that Koch specifically was wrong?)
And despite the testimony of the widow (Shanaya Rafaat) of a passenger on the flight, the play retains a clinical, unemotional view of events which leaves this only partly satisfying - the debate it inspires is more heated than the emotions. It has the intended effect of getting the audience discussing it from an intellectual point of view, but I don't think it engages the heart enough to remain memorable for too long.
Terror by Ferdinand von Schirach in a version by David Tushingham is booking until the 15th of July at the Lyric Hammersmith.
Running time: 1 hour 55 minutes including interval.
Photo credit: Tristram Kenton.
*this site tracks the international results; at the performance I saw the vote was Not Guilty, and at time of writing that's been the result at every UK performance, although there was only about 20 votes in it tonight so that could change.